Review: Lessons in Truth and Consequences in “The Totality of All Things”
The Totality of All Things Written by Erik Gernand Directed by Shannon Patterson Presented by UP Theatre Company at Theater 154 154 Christopher St, Manhattan, NYC May 7-17, 2026 Joseph Dean Anderson, DeAnna Lenhart, Colleen Clinton, and Logan Floyd. Photo by Mikiodo. At the start of UP Theater Company’s production of Erik Gernand’s The Totality of All Things , directed by Shannon Patterson, the word “TRUTH” waits on a classroom board before the play has begun in earnest. The lights are already up as the audience enters, giving us time to inhabit this journalism classroom: buzzing fluorescents overhead, chrome-and-plastic chairs, awards crowding the walls behind the teacher’s desk, institutional paint fading at the edges. The room feels immediately recognizable and intensely specific, every classroom and this classroom at once, a wholly transformed 154 Christopher Street Theatre space. That specificity matters. Gernand’s play, set in Lewiston, Indiana in the fall of 2015, begins with ...